Confounding

The issue of confounding is of central importance in any analytic epidemiological study, especially in the case of observational studies. Confounding results from non-random differences between the groups of animals being compared in relation to a second, 'confounding' exposure which is independently associated with both the exposure of interest (although not a consequence of this) and the outcome of interest (although not an effect of this). This results in the effect of the exposure of interest is 'mixed up' with the effect of the confounding exposure, and therefore an incorrect estimate of the true association. As such, confounding is viewed by many authors as a form of bias - however, unlike forms of selection and information bias, it is a natural feature of the data (in the case of an observational study), and techniques are available to account for it during analysis.

As the concept of confounding can be difficult to understand, an example is given here. Consider a cross sectional study investigating the association between the use of anthelmintics and infection with Echinococcus granulosus tapeworm in a sheep farming area where the parasite is known to exist. Initial results show that animals which were not dosed recently with anthelmintics were more likely to be infected with the tapeworm; however, further investigation shows that these dogs were also more likely to have free access to roam on the surrounding fields. In this example, free roaming is confounding the association between anthelmintic use and infection: dogs which are allowed to roam freely are both more likely to not have been dosed with anthelmintics (because their owners have more trouble restraining them for dosing) and are more likely to acquire infection (from infected dead sheep they find whilst roaming). Roaming freely is not a consequence of failure of having been dosed with anthelmintics (i.e. it does not lie on the causal pathway between anthelmintic use and infection), nor is it a consequence of having become infected with the tapeworm.