Fear-Related Feline Aggression Towards People

Key Points

Recognise and predict signs of fearful arousal. Avoid uncontrolled exposure to fear-eliciting situations and events. Identify and grade the stimuli and events that evoke fear. Desensitise and counter condition the cat to these stimuli and events, starting with stimuli that evoke the least response. Identify contexts and other stimuli that contribute to raised fearful arousal. Desensitise and counter condition the cat to these contexts and stimuli.

Introduction

Tolerance of human contact is learned as a result of early experience during the sensitive period. For example, without appropriate handling between two and seven weeks of age a cat may grow up to be wary of people and to have a predisposition towards defensively aggressive behaviour, especially if it is placed in a situation where it feels threatened. Early traumatic experience has been found to be associated with increased aggress in cats.

The majority of aggression toward people relates to inappropriate human-initiated interaction, often occurring during petting, handling an delay, and there is evidence that a significant proportion of cats become stressed by human contact even though they appear to tolerate it.

In the absence of positive experience with people, cats will avoid contact with them. However, if this is not possible and the cat is forced to remain in contact with people that it is afraid of, defensive aggressive behaviour can become an effective strategy for maintaining distance from them. With repeated negative experience in which escape and avoidance are impossible, cats may shift from an avoidant strategy to offensive aggression. By the time some of these cases are brought to the attention of the veterinary practice or referred for specific professional advice the initial fearful motivation for the behaviour may be obscured by the cat’s overt hostility and offensive behaviour. Aggression toward unfamiliar people is comparatively uncommon in cats, with the majority being defensive in nature.

Cats that are exhibiting fear-related aggression toward people will often adopt characteristic postures and use threatening vocalisation prior to a defensive swipe, which is intended to drive the threat to a greater distance. The response of the person may be significant in the progression of the problem behaviour and it should be remembered that the owner’s attempts at reassurance often intensify fear and aggression by increasing pressure on the cat removing its ability to carry out an avoidance behaviour (for example, picking the cat up to comfort it). In situations where owners try to deal with the aggressive behaviour by punishing the cat, an anticipation of the owner’s apparent ‘aggression’ may increase the cat's fear further and lead to an escalation of the problem.

Prevalence and Risk Factors

Despite a number of studies having been carried out, including surveys of referral populations and cat owners, and reports from veterinary surgeons ,there is no consensus on the prevalence of feline aggression problems.

In a Brazilian study the commonest situations that elicited aggression toward the owner were when the cat was petted or put onto a lap, during play, when startled, when observing an unfamiliar animal, when in the presence of unfamiliar people and when protecting food or territory. Aggression when petted or put on the lap was the most common. The authors found that aggression was associated with an early traumatic event and outside access. Cats that did not like being stroked or did not get on well with other animals that they had contact with were more likely to show aggression in general. However, a range of other factors, including age, sex, neuter status, accommodation, origin, and social contact with people and other cats were not significantly associated with increased aggression. However, the population of aggressive cats in this study was small (107 cats). A spanish study of 336 cats referred to a behavioural clinic found that 17.2% involved a complaint relating to aggression toward people. 43.1% of human directed aggression involved play, and 39.6% involved petting, with a significant overlap. With respect to aggression toward unfamiliar people, 70% of cases involved defensive and only 30% offensive aggression.

Aggression towards owners is probably a common but under-presented problem. This is most likely due to the owner recognising and adapting to the cat's behaviour, for example ceasing to pick the cat up or offer it unsolicited contact.

Investigation

A range of information is required for a proper investigation of the cause of aggression toward people, including:

• Information about the rearing circumstances and age of homing of the cat.
• History of the cats reaction to human contact, including any changes that have been seen over time (for example, a switch from avoidant behaviour to defensive and then offensive aggression).
• Detailed description of events in which aggression has been observed (including context, triggering events/stimuli, the cat's behaviour and the owner's reaction).
• Full investigation of health problems, particularly those likely to cause pain.
• Assessment of the cat's physical and social environment (including resource availability and distribution, conflict with ether animals in the home, and the range of opportunities available to support avoidance and escape responses).

Fear-related aggression is a motivational diagnosis and it can be associated with a variety of contexts. In some cases it may therefore be beneficial to add a contextual label as part of the diagnosis. For example, a cat that is aggressive when handled by the owner may be diagnosed as displaying "aggression associated with handling" that is fear motivated and a cat that is fearful of strangers and shows aggression to the owners when visitors are present may be diagnosed as a case of "redirected aggression", which is motivated by frustration of the fear response. In both cases "fear-related aggression" is the underlying motivational diagnosis and treatment of the cat’s underlying fear is crucial to the success of treatment but the contextual labels help the owner to understand when the behaviour may occur and to take steps to avoid it.

Treatment

It is unusual for cats to show fear-related aggression towards people outside the home environment unless cornered or handled (such as when at the veterinary clinic). Fear-related aggression towards people in the home is treated using desensitisation and counter-conditioning procedures, often supported by pheromonotherapy.

The general method employed is:

• Identify the general class of target.
• Grade the response to the target according to appearance or behaviour. Some cats are more aggressive towards men or children and may react differently according to their clothing, what the person is carrying or how they are moving. List all of the features which affect the cat’s response so that they can be introduced during training.
• Find a group of willing volunteers who will be able to act as stooges for training.
• Prepare the home environment with suitable escape places for the cat to use.
• Training is begun with the least fear and aggression evoking examples of the target class at a distance which does not trigger aggression.
• The cat may be kept on a harness and line for added safety.
• The cat is provided with food rewards as a lure to leave the escape place and explore the environment with the target present.
• Over a number of sessions, that person is brought closer, making sure that, at no point, fear or aggressive arousal is elicited. They may also walk or run around faster, make noises, move about or carry items in a way that would previously have evoked more fear and aggression. These changes are introduced gradually, systematically and with sufficient distance to avoid aggression or fear.
• Training only continues with other progressively more fear eliciting persons as the cat ceases to respond to the less evocative ones.

By identifying the elements of a person’s appearance that the cat responds to, it is possible to do a lot of training with a limited number of volunteers, who can be dressed or disguised. Above all, in this example, it is important to note that ‘unfamiliarity’ is an element of the fear so the volunteers must not try to befriend the cat at any stage during training. Familiar individuals may only be used during training if they can be disguised or kept at a distance so that the cat cannot recognise them.

Clicker Training

In some instances clicker training may be an effective way of training cats to respond appropriately to the presence of people. First of all the cat is trained to associate the sound of a click with the delivery of a small food reward. This is achieved by clicking and then dropping a piece of food approximately 20-30 times until there is some sign of positive anticipation on the part of the cat. Clicks are then only delivered when the cat carries out a specific behaviour, such as sitting. Once the cat is reliably sitting to get a click this behaviour can be ‘named’. Just as the cat is about to sit, the trainer says the command word that is intended to cue the behaviour: for example saying ‘sit’. After doing this a further 20-30 times most cats will be reliably trained to sit on cue.

Cats that have already begun to associate the presence of visitors with the availability of food treats may be asked to sit and then repeatedly clicked and treated whist they stay calm. Alternatively, the cat may simply be clicked and rewarded repeatedly throughout the period while it remains calm whilst the person is present. The limitation to this kind of training is that the sound of the click may produce a startle response that increases fear and anxiety and cats can sometimes be more difficult to motivate through the provision of food than their canine counterparts.

Pheromonotherapy

Pheromonotherapy may be used to assist behavioural therapy. The pheromone F3 (Feliway) can be used to reduce general anxiety so that the home or training environment is less threatening and it has been particularly beneficial in cases of cat to cat aggression within the same household. F4 (Felifriend) is a social pheromone used by cats to identify familiar individuals and when applied to unfamiliar individuals this can increase the cat’s tendency to approach and show affiliative behaviour. This can also be useful because it reduces escape responses. Combinations of pheromone therapies are especially helpful when the target of aggression is a member of the family or regular visitor to the household of a cat that has been recently re-homed. F4 may produce dissonant emotional states (which can induce a panic reaction) when the person or animal to whom F4 has been applied is already familiar to the cat from some aversive encounter and therefore invokes visual triggering of hostile responses. Further work in this area is essential but at the moment F4 should be used with care, applying it only to unfamiliar individuals, preferably from species with which the cat was socialised as a kitten.

Psychoactive Medication

In some cases of fear-aggression, the use of psychoactive medication may be useful to support behavioural therapy. Selegiline may be used to reduce apprehension. The effect of this drug is to increase exploratory behaviour and confidence in fearful situations. It can also enhance the perception of reward, and thereby improve responses to counterconditioning procedures. However, by encouraging the animal to move closer to the target of the fear-related aggression there is an increased risk of injury if the person startles the cat by making a sudden noise or movement. This appears to be worst during the initiation of treatment (the first 4-6 weeks of medication).

Serotonergic drugs such as Fluoxetine and Clomipramine may be used to reduce aggression where anxiety is a causative factor. However, in many cases of fear-related aggression anxiety over the consequences of launching an attack may be the only thing that prevents it. Reduction of anxiety in these cases can cause disinhibition of this anxiety, producing greater risk of attacks and injuries. Great care must therefore be taken when considering the use of any psychoactive drug; they can only be used safely and effectively after a thorough assessment of the case, and in combination with a well organised behavioural therapy plan and management to reduce risk of injury. No drug is currently licensed for the treatment of feline fear-related aggression, so informed consent must be obtained at the time of prescribing.

Prognosis

Prognosis strongly relates to the owner’s expectation of therapy. Clients who expect that a cat will become overtly friendly and tactile with all family members and visitors to the house may be disappointed.

Part of creating a good prognosis is therefore to teach clients about normal feline social behaviour and the kinds of activities that cats derive pleasure from. A balanced relationship involving appropriate levels of contact, greeting behaviour and play is likely to succeed. Cats that wish to avoid contact with certain visitors should be allowed to do so, because this represents a safe and normal response to fear, which is far more desirable than an aggressive attack.

If clients can be satisfied with this kind of situation, then the prognosis is generally good. However, cats that have already inflicted injuries without any deliberate provocation are potentially an ongoing danger. For example, cats that rush out from hiding places and attack without warning cannot be safely managed. This is why it is very important to differentiate motivations such as misdirected predatory play from genuine fear-related aggression, because the two often have different treatments and outcomes.

Prevention of Fear-Related Aggression Towards People

• Kittens should be reared in complex and stimulating environments, including having non-stressful contact with many different people and other animals.
• They should experience a wide range of domestic noises and events so that these do not evoke fear, anxiety or stress in the future.
• Immature animals should not be exposed to fearful or threatening situations or events.
• Physical punishment should NEVER be used in the training of cats or kittens.

References

Also see:

Overview of Feline Aggression